Supreme Court Tariff Ruling and Its Implications
February 24, 2026

Summary:

On February 20, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) does not authorize the President to impose broad reciprocal tariffs, and that such broad-based tariffs would require congressional approval. This removed the legal basis for many of the Trump administration’s existing tariff programs.

Court Ruling and Implications:

The Court’s ruling is predicated on the fact that tariffs are considered to be taxes, which are under the purview of Congress under Article I of the United States Constitution. While Congress does have the authority to delegate such powers to the executive branch, such delegation must be clearly stated. While the IEEPA does grant the president certain authority relating to international trade, it does not permit the executive branch to implement tariffs or duties on imports. Given that there is no explicit authority delegated, the Court held that the IEEPA is not a sufficient legal basis for implementation of such taxes.

Beyond resulting in the cancellation of the administration’s reciprocal tariffs enacted under IEEPA, there are additional implications, such as the potential for the refund of an estimated $175 billion in tax collected, though no mechanism has been established at this time. Such implications will become clearer as the case works its way back through lower courts on remand. While the Court’s holding resolves the question of whether the president has statutory authority to impose tariffs under IEEPA, it does not resolve the refund question. The opinion does not set out a refund mechanism, does not order restitution, and does not address the administrative processes by which tariffs already paid might be recovered.

It is also important to note that not all tariffs have been invalidated – only those enacted under the authority of the IEEPA. Certain tariffs impacting individual sectors (such as defense) remain in effect.

Updated Tariff Policies:

Within hours of the ruling, President Trump announced he would impose new tariffs under a different and narrower authority—Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974. As such, a proclamation was issued creating a temporary global tariff, initially 10%, later raised to 15%, on essentially all imports.

The key features of these new tariffs are as follows:

  • Effective date: February 24, 2026 at 12:01 a.m. ET
  • Duration: Up to 150 days (through July 24, 2026)
  • Authority: Section 122 (balance‑of‑payments justification)
  • Scope: Applies “across the board” on all imports unless exempted

Additionally, several categories of goods will not be subject to the new 15% duty:

  • Goods already covered by Section 232 (e.g., steel/aluminum) to avoid double‑tariffs
  • USMCA‑compliant goods from Canada and Mexico
  • Specific exceptions in sectors such as:
    • Certain critical minerals, metals, and energy products
    • Certain agricultural items (e.g., beef, tomatoes, oranges)
    • Pharmaceuticals and critical medical ingredients
    • Passenger vehicles, light/medium/heavy‑duty vehicles, and certain auto parts
    • Aerospace products
    • Informational materials and accompanied baggage
    • CAFTA-DR textiles and apparel remain duty‑free
  • Certain in-transit goods meeting specified guidelines issued by the government

What’s Next:

Exactly how IEEPA tariff refunds will be handled is unknown because this is an unprecedented situation. Because refunds are not automatic, importers must take protective steps now. Importers should identify all entries subject to IEEPA tariffs, verify whether entries are liquidated or unliquidated, gather proof of payment and entry summaries, and monitor filing deadlines. Below are the standard steps for requesting tariff refunds; however, given this unprecedented situation, this is solely for informational purposes.

  1. Post‑Summary Corrections (PSC) – For Unliquidated Entries 
  • Allows electronic correction of entry summaries to remove unlawful tariff charges. This is the way to electronically correct entry summary data presented to and accepted by U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) through CBP’s Automated Commercial Environment.
  • Must be filed within 300 days of entry or 15 days before liquidation, whichever is earlier.
  • Results in rapid refunds (1–2 business days after CBP approval).
  1. Formal Protests (CBP Form 19) – For Liquidated Entries 
  • Must be filed within 180 days after the date of liquidation.
  • Requires submission of documentary evidence (invoices, packing lists, proof of duties paid, HTS support, etc.).
  • CBP may take up to two years to adjudicate.

Conclusion:

The full implications of these changes are not yet known, but Miller Cooper is continuing to monitor applicable guidance. Should you have any questions relating to how this may impact you or your business please reach out to your contact at the firm.

 

You might also like